There are two isolated islands which have no contact with the outside world or each other. In a twist of fate, Alice and Bob find themselves alone on these separated islands just as they have reached the age of reason.
After a short time Theo, a theistic god, reveals itself to Alice and Bob independently. The revelation is the same in both cases. Theo miraculously provides writing utensils and parchment for both of them.
Ten years go by, in which, Alice and Bob on their respective islands independently worship Theo and write down the revelation they received including how to properly worship Theo. Remember they don’t know about each other and have no contact with anyone else.
After ten years Alice and Bob are rescued from their islands and tell their stories to the world.
Do you believe Alice’s and Bob’s written accounts of the revelation of Theo and how to properly worship Theo will be the same?
From the perspective of Theo, is revelation an effective way to transmit truth?
This post is in the series Thought Experiments for Believers.